| All Stars | ||||||||||||||||
| Tier 1 | ||||||||||||||||
| Catcher | Infield | Outfield | Pitcher | |||||||||||||
| 2017 | Jamie Fitzgerald | Brewers | 2017 | Ryan Burnside | Athletics | 2017 | Alex Baldock | Battalion | 2017 | Marc Charbonneau | Panthers | |||||
| Wade Wilson | Athletics | Kyle Craig | Battalion | Kevin Miller | Panthers | Nick Gazo | Brewers | |||||||||
| Chris Kushneriuk | Mudd | Jeff Skelhorne-Gross | Ponies | Josh Soffer | Battalion | |||||||||||
| Geoff Magnus | Brewers | |||||||||||||||
| 2016 | Eric Proulx | Riverhawks | 2016 | Kyle Craig | Battalion | 2016 | Alex Baldock | Battalion | 2016 | Bobby Brooks | Cubs | |||||
| Jeff Skelhorne-Gross | Ponies | Geoff Magnus | Brewers | Felix Septimo | Athletics | John Ivimey | Ponies | |||||||||
| Adam Oattes | Brewers | Jeff Skelhorne-Gross | Ponies | Josh Soffer | Battalion | |||||||||||
| Steve Renaud | Battalion | |||||||||||||||
| 2015 | Eric Proulx | Riverhawks | 2015 | Kyle Craig | Battalion | 2015 | Shawn Hopewell | Athletics | 2015 | Bobby Brooks | Cubs | |||||
| Geoff Magnus | Brewers | Kevin Miller | Panthers | Derek Howe | Ponies | |||||||||||
| Adam Oattes | Brewers | Jeff Skelhorne-Gross | Ponies | Josh Soffer | Battalion | |||||||||||
| Steve Renaud | Battalion | |||||||||||||||
| Tier 2 | ||||||||||||||||
| Catcher | Infield | Outfield | Pitcher | |||||||||||||
| 2017 | Austin Flanagan | Cornwall | 2017 | Jay Flannigan | Cornwall | 2017 | Doug McLean | Outlaws | 2017 | Dave Barnes | Expos | |||||
| Eric Proulx | Marc Sports | Jules Hubert | Marc Sports | Brett Verberne | Braves | Alex Goyette | Marc Sports | |||||||||
| Brad McKay | Cardinals | Alex Villeneuve | Marc Sports | Jordan Kritsch | Cardinals | |||||||||||
| Jamie Pounder | Outlaws | |||||||||||||||
| 2016 | Kyle Baker | Expos | 2016 | Scott Adams | Expos | 2016 | Rudy Vallejos | Mudd | 2016 | Dave Barnes | Expos | |||||
| Martin Charron | Marc Sports | Ryan Chow | Mudd | Tyler Munro | Mudd | Alex Goyette | Marc Sports | |||||||||
| Ethan Nodwell | Winchester Sox | Corey Valois | Expos | Jordan Kritsch | Cardinals | |||||||||||
| Scott Willis | Misfits | |||||||||||||||
| 2015 | Matt Ware | Winchester Sox | 2015 | Scott Adams | Expos | 2015 | Mark Bond | Sweat Sox | 2015 | Dave Barnes | Expos | |||||
| Ryan Chow | Mudd | Ben Miller | Cornwall | Jay Flannigan | Cornwall | |||||||||||
| Jay Flannigan | Cornwall | Geoff Ruggiero | Expos | Eric White | Sweat Sox | |||||||||||
| Brad McKay | Cardinals | |||||||||||||||
| Tier 3 | ||||||||||||||||
| Catcher | Infield | Outfield | Pitcher | |||||||||||||
| 2017 | Rob Chapman | Mavericks | 2017 | Andrew Belmore | Rockets | 2017 | Louis Gadbois | Black Sox | 2017 | Peter Gauthier | Misfits | |||||
| Marc Hughes | Lumberjacks | Peter Gauthier | Misfits | Stephane Leclair | Dukes | Jesse Gratton | Sharks | |||||||||
| Chris Goguen | Sharks | Jay Murfitt | Sharks | Nick Lenardon | Rockets | |||||||||||
| Ron Martelle | Red Sox | |||||||||||||||
| 2016 | Rob Chapman | Mavericks | 2016 | Joel Sanscartier | Lumberjacks | 2016 | Trevor Williams | Dukes | 2016 | Phil Martin | Black Sox | |||||
| Matt Kaeding | Bombers | Chris Goguen | Sharks | Stephane Leclair | Dukes | Jeremy Pluym | Mavericks | |||||||||
| Phil Martin | Black Sox | Jay Murfitt | Sharks | Nick Lenardon | Rockets | |||||||||||
| Jeff Carr | Rockets | |||||||||||||||
| 2015 | Dave Maclennan | Misfits | 2015 | Peter Gauthier | Misfits | 2015 | Isaac Cockburn | Misfits | 2015 | Peter Gauthier | Misfits | |||||
| Chris Goguen | Sharks | Stephane Leclair | Dukes | Darren Hempel | Mavericks | |||||||||||
| Jamie Pounder | Black Sox | Jay Murfitt | Sharks | Nick Lenardon | Rockets | |||||||||||
| Jeff Pyne | Sharks | |||||||||||||||
| Tier 4 | ||||||||||||||||
| Catcher | Infield | Outfield | Pitcher | |||||||||||||
| 2017 | Ron Hall | Vampiros | 2017 | Paul Dubinski | Lynx | 2017 | Derek Brennan | Knights | 2017 | Sam Cudmore | Strykers | |||||
| Cory McCarney | Lynx | Chris Embury | Heat | Cody Earle | Irish | Paul Dubinski | Lynx | |||||||||
| Darren Trenholm | Vampiros | Stef Lavictoire | Coyotes | Dan Lacroix | Strykers | |||||||||||
| Oliver Varrette | Knights | |||||||||||||||
| Catcher | Infield | Outfield | Pitcher | |||||||||||||
| 2016 | Rob Archambault | Cuba | 2016 | Anthony Oliveira | Lynx | 2016 | Mathieu Migneault | Irish | 2016 | Darren Trenholm | Vampiros | |||||
| Ron Hall | Vampiros | Jake Gaudet | Knights | Derek Brennan | Knights | Dan LaCroix | Strykers | |||||||||
| Dave Crane | Vampiros | Matt Healy | Bandits | Shaun Van Allen | Knights | |||||||||||
| Dan Paquin | Irish | |||||||||||||||
| 2015 | Hank Beelen | Braumeisters | 2015 | Paul Brown | Coyotes | 2015 | Alex Priest-Brown | Irish | 2015 | Zach Huntley | Capitals | |||||
| Olivier Smith | Irish | Erik Shilts | Coyotes | Pat Hurtubise | Capitals | |||||||||||
| Jordan Potechin | Vampiros | Brett Smith | Irish | Matt Wellstead | Capitals | |||||||||||
| Oliver Varrette | Knights | |||||||||||||||